Tesla model Y vs. BMW iX1 - Which electric SUV is better?

As the electric vehicle (EV) market grows, competition between automakers like Tesla and BMW is heating up. In this comparison, we’ll look at how two of the most popular electric SUVs – the Tesla Model Y and the BMW iX1 – stack up. Both vehicles offer excellent features, but there are clear differences in terms of performance, technology, and overall value.

Performance: Tesla takes the lead

When it comes to raw power and acceleration, the Tesla Model Y outpaces the BMW iX1. The Model Y is equipped with a 92 kWh battery and generates 342 horsepower (255 kW). This allows it to accelerate from 0 to 100 km/h in just 5.7 seconds. On the other hand, the BMW iX1, with its 66 kWh battery and 201 horsepower (150 kW), takes 8.2 seconds to reach the same speed.

In performance tests, Tesla earned a 4.6-star rating, surpassing BMW’s 4.3 stars. If quick acceleration and power are priorities, the Model Y is the better choice.

Driving experience: BMW’s refinement

While the Tesla Model Y dominates in performance, the BMW iX1 scores higher in driving comfort and handling. The iX1, being slightly smaller and lighter, offers more refined driving dynamics, particularly in city driving and tight spaces. Auto Express awarded the iX1 4.3 stars for its driving behavior, compared to 4.0 stars for the Model Y.

Despite Tesla’s strength in straight-line speed, BMW enthusiasts will appreciate the driving precision and overall ride comfort of the iX1.

Efficiency and cost: Tesla shines again

One area where Tesla consistently excels is efficiency. The Model Y received 4.7 stars for its low running costs and high energy efficiency, while the iX1 was close behind with 4.3 stars. Tesla’s ability to deliver more range from its larger battery gives it an edge for those who value long-distance driving on a single charge.

In terms of overall costs, the Tesla Model Y and BMW iX1 are priced similarly, but the lower running costs and superior range of the Tesla make it a more attractive option for families looking to reduce long-term expenses.

Interior and technology: BMW’s Upscale Appeal

Although Tesla’s minimalist design has its fans, the BMW iX1 stands out in terms of interior quality and tech features. BMW earned 4.5 stars in this category, surpassing Tesla’s 4.2 stars. The iX1’s infotainment system and materials offer a more premium feel, appealing to drivers who value luxury and detailed craftsmanship.

While the Tesla Model Y is built with cutting-edge technology, including its autonomous driving capabilities and infotainment system, the more upscale interior of the iX1 might be more attractive to those who prioritize comfort and aesthetic.

Which is the better family EV?

In conclusion, both the Tesla Model Y and BMW iX1 are excellent electric SUVs, each with its own strengths. If you’re looking for superior performance and range, the Tesla Model Y is the clear winner. However, if interior quality and driving refinement are more important to you, the BMW iX1 might be the better choice.

For families, the Tesla Model Y edges out its competition with a final score of 4.5 stars compared to 4.0 stars for the BMW iX1, thanks to its efficiency, performance, and advanced technology.